Guide
Online therapy vs in-person therapy: which is right for you?
A plain-language comparison — effectiveness, privacy, convenience, cost and Medicare — to help you choose what actually fits your life.
Does online therapy actually work?
This is usually the first question — and a fair one. Research on telehealth psychology has grown substantially, particularly for anxiety and depression, and the broad finding is reassuring: outcomes from video sessions are generally comparable to face-to-face therapy. Suitability still depends on the person and the issue, but for most common concerns the format isn't the deciding factor — the therapeutic relationship and the quality of the work are.
That includes more structured approaches like EMDR for trauma, which can be delivered safely online with the right preparation and pacing.
Where each one shines
Online therapy
- No commute — sessions from home, work or your car
- Easier to fit around work, study and caring responsibilities
- Wider choice of psychologists, not just those in your suburb
- Comfort of a familiar space — many people open up more easily
In-person therapy
- A dedicated, private space outside your home
- Helpful if your living situation makes privacy hard
- Preferred by some for body-based or non-verbal work
- A clear separation between therapy and daily life
Privacy and your space
Online sessions run over an encrypted video link, and records are stored securely. The bigger privacy question is usually on your side: do you have a room where you won't be overheard? A closed bedroom, a parked car or a quiet office all work. If that's genuinely hard to arrange at home, an in-person consulting room can be the more private option, not the other way around.
Medicare. Eligible telehealth sessions attract the same Medicare rebate as in-person sessions, when you have a Mental Health Treatment Plan from your GP. Format doesn't change the rebate.
When in-person is the better fit
Online isn't the right answer for everyone. In-person tends to be the better choice if you don't have a private space, if you're in acute crisis and need immediate face-to-face support, or if you simply know you do your best thinking outside the house. Many people find a mix works — online most weeks for convenience, with the option of in-person where it makes sense.
How to decide
A useful question is: what's most likely to keep you turning up consistently? Therapy works when sessions actually happen, week after week. If the commute, the time off work or the waiting room would chip away at that, online makes consistency easier. If your home environment makes it hard to switch into the session, in-person may be worth the effort.
Frequently asked questions
Is online therapy actually as effective?
For common concerns like anxiety, depression and stress, research suggests telehealth therapy can deliver outcomes comparable to in-person sessions. What matters most is the fit with your psychologist and the consistency of the work — both translate well online.
What about more complex issues like trauma?
Structured trauma work — including EMDR — can be delivered safely online with the right preparation, pacing and grounding plan. Your psychologist will assess suitability with you and adapt the approach to the format.
Will I feel as connected to my psychologist over video?
Most people find the connection forms within a session or two, much like in person. Eye contact, tone of voice and a shared focus carry across video well. If something feels off, it's worth raising — small adjustments usually fix it.
Is online therapy cheaper?
Fees for online sessions are usually the same as in-person, but you save on travel time and costs. Medicare rebates apply equally to eligible telehealth and in-person sessions when you have a Mental Health Treatment Plan.
Can I mix online and in-person sessions?
Yes — many people do. Online sessions for convenience, with occasional in-person if and when it suits, is a common and workable rhythm.
General information only. This article isn't a substitute for personal psychological advice. If you're in distress, contact your GP or Lifeline on 13 11 14. In an emergency, call 000.
Try online therapy with Riya
Telehealth psychology across Australia, from wherever you feel comfortable. Book a time or send a question first.